The Importance of Trial By Fire
Author - Gabriel Russell - Philosophy Student at Fordham University - Honors College - Class of 2027
Trial by Fire Learning
The question of learning is at the heart of Mountain Goat Movement’s mission. What is learning? What does knowledge require? At Mountain Goat Movement we believe in a hands-on approach to learning that encourages, not incorporates, failure and inexperience.
Though our school system may be the sculpture of younger generations, the classroom itself is an imperfect solution to learning. Western emphasis on efficiency, standardization, and control has reduced education to metrics, testing, and tidy rows of desks. But learning is not linear, and it is rarely neat. It’s messy, slow, and often uncomfortable. In traditional classrooms, students are rewarded for compliance, not curiosity. The result? A generation of young people who are often disengaged, disinterested, and disconnected from the deeper purpose of education.
According to a study done by The National Association of State Boards of Education, up to 60% of high school students report feeling disengaged in school. The longer students stay in the system, the more disengaged they become. This isn’t because they lack intelligence or motivation, it’s because the system rarely challenges them in ways that feel embodied.
At Mountain Goat Movement, we believe learning should be dynamic, active, and tested in the real world. That’s why we turn to a more ancient model - one rooted not in efficiency, but in experience. In Ancient Greece, knowledge was divided into different kinds: techne (formalized knowledge), and mētis (cunning, adaptive intelligence). The modern classroom prioritizes techne, but leaves little room for the wisdom that emerges through struggle, failure, and practice - mētis. That’s where we come in.
Many people are seemingly under the impression that learning can happen anywhere provided the necessary materials are present. For instance, If I were to teach someone to build a fire we would have to go outside. However, Math, English, Science and History can all be taught indoors. Students need paper, a pencil and maybe a computer. Proponents of Techne, or formalized knowledge, posit that anything can be learned through a general curriculum. Yet these curriculi avoid the nuances and nature of the individual.
The key word to learning at MGM is novelty. Novelty in what one encounters in the outdoors, novelty in the lessons they bring away, and novelty in themselves. Expeditions outdoors are obviously an opportunity for practical knowledge. Yet they are also a gateway for personal discovery. Learning is always a more meaningful experience when given an environment that bends to the bruiosity and interests of the individual. The outdoors is what allows for metis to happen. It is what spurs young men and women to feel inspired, to challenge themselves, and to take risks.
How Mountain Goat Creates the Fire
At Mountain Goat Movement, we don’t simulate challenge. We create real challenge, within a framework of safety, reflection, and mentorship. Our expeditions aren’t just field trips with backpacks. They’re designed as intentional pressure cookers for personal growth. When we take young people into the wild, we take them into a place where failure is not just possible, it’s necessary. The weather won’t bend to your plan. The trail might not match the map. You will get tired. You might get lost. And in those moments, mētis begins to emerge.
When a student misses a trail marker and has to reorient the group… when a pack is too heavy because they overpacked gear… when two friends argue and still have ten miles to hike together… this is where wisdom forms. Not because an instructor explained it, but because the experience demanded it.
Each Mountain Goat expedition is built to foster:
-
Reading the environment, not a worksheet
-
Building trust in peers through shared adversity
-
Learning to adjust under pressure, without quitting
-
Understanding what you're capable of when things don’t go as planned
We don’t just teach outdoor skills. We teach how to fail forward. How to persist when no one’s watching. How to lead when you’re cold, tired, and unsure. That is real learning. And it stays with you, long after the trail ends.
In the Greek tradition, techne without mētis is brittle. But when cunning, craft, and courage come together, you don’t just know something. You own it. Our students return home a little more grounded, a little more confident, and a lot more alive to their ownmost potential. That’s what the fire does.
